Why we feel devastated when friendship fails

Mariyon Slany October 2024

The low hum of ambiguous loss

Picture of person in forest all alone without friends

What is terribly haunting are the gaps left in us by others, and I think of my dead father as I write this. Having suddenly lost him in my mid 20s, I often think of him and wonder where he would be in his life cycle, i.e. how he had managed retirement, would he be travelling back to Europe or maybe would his body have been so exhausted by a lifetime of physical and intellectual work that he would be resting a lot.  It makes me sad. What I have done is grieve for his loss. I have partaken in rituals of mourning and spoken about him in the past tense; which was exceedingly difficult in the first year after he died. This was publicly okay to do and expected of me, as other members of my family grieved.  I was given space to feel sad, and platitudes were uttered by other people when I used the words ‘my father’ and ‘died early’ in the same sentence.


However, I have had a different experience with the loss of a best friend.  She was vibrant and always interested in what I had to share with her, and we shared the same shorthand and a similar sense of humour. We pursued similar creative goals and worked on a production together, but ultimately went through life stages at different times which seemed too difficult to negotiate.  Plus, I had met her through another close friend and ultimately that friend took precedence for her – because she was loyal to her ‘first friend’ rather than me, with whom she had much more in common, the friendship faltered and with no big argument we drifted apart in a short amount of time.   


It doesn’t mean that I don’t still think about her and wonder how and where she would be in my life if we were still at least distant friends. I have tried several times and she doesn’t seem able to pick up the thread of our intense friendship that would now look like a 'comfortable being with each other' friendship.  What I really struggle with is the ambiguous loss inherent in this.  This is someone who for at least 7 years I talked with at least once a day, sometimes both morning and night, and texted during the day numerous times as well, and she has for over 15 years now, not been any part of my life, despite my several attempts to reconnect. 


This is more of a disenfranchised grief; she was not my lover, not my family member, not even a childhood friend, but someone I met as an adult who I forged a close emotional and mental connection with and had formative experiences with. I am still very alone in expressing how I truly feel about it. My husband would - up until a few years back when I would send an invite for our annual Christmas party - ask me what I wanted from those communications, and tell me to ‘move on’ that there was no point resurrecting an old friendship. 


The thing is with loss from death we can focus on practical aspects associated with that momentous change in our life; we can DO something to keep us distracted from the grief.  If we are ‘ghosted’ by someone, apart from sifting through photos and putting them away where we can't see them or deleting them, there is nothing much practical to do, and I've realised our community doesn’t give space to this kind of loss.  This low hum of mourning permeates many parts of my life still, as I wonder what stage of life is she in.  This not knowing, of considering that this loss may actually be forever, is the unending sense of it, that leads to confusion, avoidance or distraction i.e. fantasy making about a different possible outcome.

If you’re mourning a friend, feeling lost in the aftermath of a big decision or just simply not sure what you're feeling, is there someone in your corner? A good listener, Mariyon will quickly understand the nuances and work with you to strengthen your sense of being whole again. Men and women are welcome.


Feel free to call Mariyon on 0430 183 893 for a preliminary chat and see if she can help.

Book Appointment

Mariyon Slany Psychotherapist Blog

By Mariyon Slany January 30, 2025
Feeling totally worn out? Racing away from another emotional pressure point?
By Guest writer Ian Shann October 4, 2024
Are you looking for tips on how to co-parent amicably after a separation or divorce? Family mediator Ian Shann of Move On Mediation in Perth shares his valuable tips from over 30 years of helping separating parents move on with their lives.
3 people talking by the water's edge and having conversation
By The Listening Guide June 14, 2023
The gradual screening of phone calls was something I have observed increasing over the past 15 years, with the associated upswing in having appointments to catch up rather than just organically dropping in on friends. I have also noticed this coincides with the phrase 'overthinking things' which is so prevalent today. My mind reflects that when clients tell me they had a conversation, or discussed an important issue with a friend, room-mate or partner finding that it is more than likely they are referring to a text based message, and not a face to face conversation. Perhaps 'overthinking' is associated to writing, rewriting or deleting a text based message prior to sending it. A client mentioned that an ex partner didn't want to speak on the phone because of potential confrontation; the assumption being that a phone call will lead to conflict. Is this a generational experience? That ellipsis's or silences can only be permissable if we have grown up assuming there is an organic nature to conversation that allows for the other to respond both verbally and non verbally. If you can't craft the perfect response then you don't' want to engage with the other person. It's almost saying - I want to put you on pause to allow myself to think of the perfect response. The saying that 'conversation is an art' goes back 100s' of years, and yet is never true-er; with people predicting the end of conversational art from the 1950's. Now it seems emotions becoming status updates rather than something to be explored in a conversation . “The art of conversation is the art of hearing as well as of being heard.” ― William Hazlitt, Selected Essays, 1778-1830 The invention of the rotary phone in 1892 already caused people anxiety. The fear was that telephone communication was somehow magical and we might be 'taken over' by using the phone to talk with someone. The modern rotary dial came in from 1919 which is when 'dialling' starting to be used in our lexicon, and of course the ubiqitious mobile phone from the 1990's. This seems to have led to a reluctantence now to pick up the phone to just chat? These are some reasons I've heard: We feel that we are short of time; That texting allows us to multi-task; That we can't predict what will happen in the conversation and we are becoming used to curated information at all levels; We may not know what to say; or we simply don't want to have that much personal connection because we feel overwhelmed by out lives as it is. We are losing out on allowing the other to enter into the conversation and influence what we are saying or feeling. Providing a pause for the engagement of other to come into the conversation is part of dialogue rather than polemical statements. I have a metaphor that I use which is 'my antennae are way out of on stalks' to indicate when someone is more sensitised to the world and other people's emotions. Perhaps we are trying to protect ourselves from the raw experience of other's emotional selves which results in pulling out antennae back into ourselves like a snail.
Show More